Head-to-Head Comparison
Healthy Paws vs. Nationwide
Unlimited specialist vs. Fortune 100 legacy carrier
Last updated: March 2026 | Compared by Mike (AAI, PRC, SBCS, CCIC)
Our Verdict
Healthy Paws wins decisively for dogs and cats with unlimited coverage, faster claims, and lower premiums. Nationwide wins only if you have exotic pets — it's the sole major carrier covering birds, reptiles, and other exotics.
Healthy Paws
4.5/5
Unlimited coverage with no payout caps
Nationwide
3.8/5
Exotic pets and Fortune 100 financial backing
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Coverage Limits
Healthy Paws
Unlimited
Nationwide
$10K annual (Whole Pet)
Healthy Paws' unlimited payouts dwarf Nationwide's $10K annual cap.
Monthly Premiums
Healthy Paws
$25–$90
Nationwide
$35–$100
Healthy Paws offers better coverage at lower premiums.
Claims Speed
Healthy Paws
2–10 days
Nationwide
5–30 days
Healthy Paws processes claims significantly faster.
Exotic Pet Coverage
Healthy Paws
Dogs & cats only
Nationwide
Dogs, cats, birds, reptiles, exotics
Nationwide is the only major carrier covering exotic pets.
Financial Stability
Healthy Paws
Chubb (A+ AM Best)
Nationwide
Nationwide (A+ AM Best)
Both are backed by A+ rated insurers with massive asset bases.
Wellness Coverage
Healthy Paws
Not available
Nationwide
Included in Whole Pet plan
Nationwide includes wellness coverage; Healthy Paws does not offer it.
Track Record
Healthy Paws
Since 2009
Nationwide
Since 1982
Nationwide has 40+ years in pet insurance vs. Healthy Paws' 15+ years.
Get Your Free Quote
See how much you could save with our top-rated carrier.
Get a Free Healthy Paws Quote