In-Depth Review
Pumpkin Pet Insurance Review
Our Verdict
Best for owners of senior pets and those who want a single, simplified plan structure with no orthopedic waiting period — especially valuable for breeds prone to cruciate or hip issues. The 80%/90% reimbursement floor and lack of a 70% tier mean you cannot trade coverage for a cheaper premium.
Coverage Limit
$7,000–Unlimited annual (varies by species)
Monthly Premium
$20–$95
Deductible Options
$100, $250, $500, $1,000
Reimbursement
80%, 90%
Quick Facts
Pros
- No separate orthopedic waiting period — cruciate and hip dysplasia covered after the standard 14-day wait
- No upper age limit for enrollment (rare among major carriers)
- PumpkinNow direct payment for emergency claims of $1,000 or more
- Higher reimbursement floor (80% minimum) than competitors offering 70% tiers
- 10% multi-pet discount on each additional pet enrolled
Cons
- —Founded in 2020 — limited long-term claims and renewal-pricing track record
- —No 70% reimbursement option, so the cheapest tier is structurally more expensive
- —Preventive Essentials is a separate non-insurance product, not bundled wellness coverage
- —14-day accident waiting period is longer than the 2-day window at Lemonade, Spot, and Embrace
- —Claim turnaround averages 10–14 days — slower than Trupanion's direct pay or Lemonade's AI
Overview
Pumpkin entered the pet insurance market in 2020, founded by veterans of the Petplan and Petco insurance teams. Although it is one of the newer brands, the underlying paper is written by Crum & Forster — specifically United States Fire Insurance Company or Independence American Insurance Company depending on your state — the same financially backed underwriter that powers ASPCA Pet Health Insurance and Spot.
The product itself is a single accident & illness plan with a clean structure: pick your deductible, your reimbursement rate (80% or 90%), and your annual limit. There are no plan tiers, no schedule of benefits, and — unusually — no separate orthopedic waiting period. Pumpkin pairs the insurance with a separately sold non-insurance product called Preventive Essentials, which refunds the cost of routine wellness care.
Coverage Details
Pumpkin's accident & illness plan covers hereditary and congenital conditions (hip dysplasia, IVDD, heart disease), cancer treatment, dental illness (extractions and periodontal disease — not routine cleanings), behavioral therapy, prescription medications, alternative therapies including acupuncture and chiropractic, and microchipping. Hereditary conditions are covered from day one of the policy with no surcharge or rider, which matches the strongest carriers in the market.
Preventive Essentials is technically NOT insurance — it is an optional refund program sold alongside the insurance policy. For dogs it refunds the annual wellness exam fee, two vaccines, one fecal test, and one heartworm/tick test. For cats it refunds the wellness exam fee, one vaccine, and one fecal test. Because it is not insurance, it is not regulated as such, and the refund structure pays the actual cost of services up to the package allowance rather than a fixed-dollar wellness benefit. Worth understanding the distinction at purchase.
Pricing & Premiums
Pumpkin's monthly premiums typically run $20–$45 for cats and $40–$95 for dogs, depending on breed, age, zip code, and the deductible/reimbursement combination chosen. A young mixed-breed dog in a moderate-cost zip with a $250 deductible and 80% reimbursement at the $20,000 annual limit usually lands in the $50–$65/month range — not the cheapest option in the market, but mid-pack.
The absence of a 70% reimbursement tier means there is no "budget" version of a Pumpkin policy. If you want to lower your premium, you do it by raising the deductible (up to $1,000) or lowering the annual limit, not by accepting a smaller share of the bill. For owners who would rather guarantee an 80%+ reimbursement, this structural choice is a feature; for owners trying to minimize monthly cost, it is a constraint.
Claims Experience
Standard claims are submitted through the Pumpkin app or web portal — upload the itemized invoice, the claims team reviews it, and reimbursement is sent via direct deposit, eCheck, or mailed check. Average processing time is 10–14 business days, which is on the slower side of the industry but consistent with other Crum & Forster–backed carriers like ASPCA and Spot.
Pumpkin's most distinctive claims feature is PumpkinNow: for eligible emergency claims of $1,000 or more, the company can deposit the reimbursement to your bank in as little as 15 minutes — before you even have to pay the vet out of pocket. This is functionally similar to Trupanion's direct vet pay but routed through your account rather than the clinic, and it only triggers above the $1,000 threshold.
Expert Take
From Mike Donaldson, AAI, PRC, SBCS, CCIC
Here is what I tell clients who are considering Pumpkin: the headline feature is the absence of an orthopedic waiting period. Most carriers — Embrace, Spot, Pets Best — apply a 6-month waiting period to cruciate ligaments, hip dysplasia, and other orthopedic conditions, which can be a real problem if you own a Labrador, a Newfoundland, a Rottweiler, or any breed that tears an ACL between months two and six of the policy. Pumpkin treats orthopedic conditions like any other illness: 14 days, then covered. For breeds with elevated joint risk, that is a meaningful structural advantage worth more than people realize.
The 80%/90%-only reimbursement structure is the part I am more skeptical of. Pumpkin frames the lack of a 70% tier as a consumer benefit — "we won't sell you a watered-down policy" — but the practical effect is that it removes the cheapest version of the product from the menu. If you are a young, healthy mixed-breed cat in a low-cost zip, you cannot dial down to 70% to bring the premium under $20/month the way you can with Spot or Lemonade. That floor matters more for budget-conscious buyers than the marketing language admits.
The Preventive Essentials structure is genuinely unusual and worth flagging. Because it is sold as a separate non-insurance refund product, it is not subject to state insurance regulation. That sounds like an obscure technicality, but it means the consumer protections that apply to your policy (rate review, complaint handling, market conduct exams) do not all apply to your wellness package. For most pet owners, this is a footnote — but if you are deciding between Pumpkin's Preventive Essentials and a true bundled wellness rider like Embrace's Wellness Rewards, understand that you are buying two different kinds of products. And remember that Pumpkin was founded in 2020 — you are getting a five-year track record on renewal pricing, not a fifteen-year one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Real answers to the questions pet owners actually ask about Pumpkin.
Ready to Get Covered?
Compare Pumpkin with our top-rated carrier, Healthy Paws.
Related Comparisons
Related Articles
Pre-Existing Conditions in Pet Insurance: The Complete Guide
Pre-existing conditions are the #1 reason pet insurance claims get denied. Here's exactly how they work, what counts, and how to protect yourself before it's too late.
Pet Insurance and Pre-Existing Conditions: Are There Any Workarounds?
There are no true loopholes for pre-existing conditions in pet insurance. There are, however, legitimate paths that allow some curable conditions to become eligible after a symptom-free period. Here is exactly how those paths work and which carriers offer them.
Pet Insurance That Covers Dental: Which Plans Include It?
Dental disease is the most common condition treated by vets — and the most commonly excluded by insurance. Here's exactly which plans cover what, and how to avoid the most expensive gap in pet insurance coverage.