Head-to-Head Comparison
Nationwide vs. ASPCA
Fortune 100 legacy vs. trusted nonprofit brand
Our Verdict
ASPCA wins for most dog and cat owners with better coverage limits, lower premiums, and more plan flexibility. Nationwide wins only for exotic pet owners or those who prioritize Fortune 100 financial backing.
Nationwide
3.8/5
Exotic pets and Fortune 100 financial backing
ASPCA
3.9/5
Brand trust with competitive mid-tier pricing
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Coverage Limits
Nationwide
$10K annual
ASPCA
$5K–Unlimited
ASPCA offers an unlimited coverage option; Nationwide caps at $10K.
Monthly Premiums
Nationwide
$35–$100
ASPCA
$20–$75
ASPCA premiums are significantly lower across most demographics.
Exotic Pet Coverage
Nationwide
Birds, reptiles, exotics
ASPCA
Dogs & cats only
Nationwide is the only option for exotic pet owners.
Deductible Options
Nationwide
$250 only
ASPCA
$100, $250, $500
ASPCA offers more deductible flexibility.
Claims Speed
Nationwide
5–30 days
ASPCA
5–14 days
ASPCA processes claims faster on average.
Financial Stability
Nationwide
Nationwide (A+ AM Best)
ASPCA
Crum & Forster (A AM Best)
Nationwide's Fortune 100 status provides superior financial backing.
Wellness Coverage
Nationwide
Included
ASPCA
Optional add-on
Both offer wellness coverage, though structured differently.
Expert Take
Mike
Licensed Insurance Professional (AAI, PRC, SBCS, CCIC)
Two legacy brands with very different pet insurance products. Nationwide brings Fortune 100 financial strength and exotic pet coverage. ASPCA (underwritten by C&F Insurance) brings brand trust from the animal welfare world and competitive pricing.
Neither offers unlimited coverage — Nationwide caps at $7,500–$10,000 on standard plans, ASPCA at $5,000–unlimited depending on the plan tier. ASPCA's pricing is generally 15–20% lower than Nationwide for comparable coverage. Nationwide's Whole Pet plan is their premium offering and competes well, but at a significant price premium.
The ASPCA brand carries emotional weight with pet owners, but it is important to understand that ASPCA pet insurance is a licensing deal — the actual insurer is Crum & Forster. For most pet owners comparing these two, ASPCA offers better value. Nationwide wins for exotic pets and for customers who want to bundle with existing Nationwide policies.
Get Your Free Quote
See how much you could save with our top-rated carrier.
Get a Free Healthy Paws QuoteRead the Full Reviews
Related Comparisons
Other head-to-head matchups involving Nationwide and ASPCA