5 Costly Mistakes People Make When Buying Pet Insurance
Mike
AAI, PRC, SBCS, CCIC
After reviewing thousands of policies across my insurance career, these are the errors I see most often — and they can cost you thousands when you need coverage most.
Mistake #1: Waiting Too Long to Enroll
This is the single most expensive mistake in pet insurance. Every condition your pet develops before enrollment becomes a pre-existing condition — permanently excluded from coverage, regardless of which carrier you choose.
The math is simple: If you enroll a healthy 8-week-old puppy at $35/month, you’ll pay about $420/year. One covered ACL surgery ($5,000) pays for 12 years of premiums.
Mistake #2: Choosing the Lowest Premium Without Understanding Why It’s Low
A $15/month pet insurance policy exists for a reason — and that reason is usually some combination of: low annual coverage limits ($5,000–$10,000), per-incident caps, high deductibles, and exclusions for common conditions.
Compare this to Healthy Paws at $35–$45/month with truly unlimited coverage. The premium difference over a year is about $240–$360, but the coverage difference in a catastrophic scenario is potentially $50,000+.
Mistake #3: Not Understanding Waiting Periods
Every pet insurance policy has waiting periods — typically 14–15 days for accidents and 14–30 days for illnesses. The mistake isn’t the waiting period itself — it’s not planning for it.
Pro tip: Healthy Paws has a 15-day waiting period for both accidents and illnesses, with no extended orthopedic waiting period. Trupanion has a 5-day accident waiting period — the shortest in the industry.
Mistake #4: Ignoring the Underwriter
Your pet insurance company is only as strong as the insurance company backing it. When you file a $15,000 cancer claim, you want to know that the entity paying it has the financial resources to do so.
Healthy Paws is underwritten by Chubb (ACE American Insurance Company) — rated A+ by AM Best with over $200 billion in assets. Trupanion is its own publicly traded insurance company (NASDAQ: TRUP).
Mistake #5: Switching Carriers to Save Money
Switching carriers means all existing conditions become pre-existing at the new carrier, waiting periods restart from zero, and you lose claims history that may have been building toward your deductible.
Instead of switching: Adjust your deductible or reimbursement percentage to lower premiums while keeping the same carrier and coverage continuity.
You Might Also Like
Pre-Existing Conditions in Pet Insurance: The Complete Guide
Pre-existing conditions are the #1 reason pet insurance claims get denied. Here's exactly how they work, what counts, and how to protect yourself before it's too late.
How to File a Pet Insurance Claim (Step-by-Step Guide)
Filing your first pet insurance claim can be confusing. Here's the exact process for every major carrier, plus pro tips to get reimbursed faster.
When Should You Get Pet Insurance? The Age-by-Age Guide
The best time to get pet insurance was the day you got your pet. The second best time is today. Here's exactly why timing matters and what changes at each life stage.